Over a barrel: Sudan mediators face tough choices
With the Sudanese capital, Khartoum, transformed from tranquil city to war zone, Saudi Arabia and the US have called the warring parties to Jeddah to seek agreement on a ceasefire. But as Sudan expert Alex de Waal says, it will just be a short-term, emergency step.
There is a dilemma for mediators: whatever decision they take on the format and agenda for emergency talks will determine the path of peace-making in Sudan through to its conclusion.
To silence the guns, the American and Saudi diplomats will deal only with the rival generals who have each sent a three-person negotiating team to Jeddah.
The agenda is a humanitarian ceasefire, a monitoring mechanism and corridors for aid. Neither side wants to open negotiations towards a political agreement.
The civilian parties and neighbourhood resistance committees, whose non-violent protests brought down the authoritarian regime of long-time leader Omar al-Bashir four years ago, will be onlookers.
It will not be easy to get the two generals to agree to any kind of ceasefire.
The army chief, Gen Abdel Fattah al-Burhan, will insist that he represents the legitimate government. He will label Gen Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, better known as "Hemedti", as a rebel.
But Hemedti, his de facto deputy until the clashes, will demand equal status for the two sides.
He will want a freeze-in-place, leaving his paramilitary Rapid Support Forces (RSF) fighters in control of much of Khartoum. Gen Burhan will require a return to the positions in the days before the clashes began.
Getting a compromise means hard bargaining with the generals.
The mediators need to gain their confidence and assure them that, if they make concessions now, that will not leave them exposed and vulnerable.
The downside is that the two warring parties will then demand the dominant role in political talks and an agenda that suits their interests.
One thing on which Burhan and Hemedti - and the Arab neighbours - agree is that they do not want a democratic government, which had been on the cards before the fighting began. The two military men had run the country since the 2019 which ousted Bashir, refusing to hand power to civilians.
Another point of agreement will be amnesty for war crimes.
Negotiations dominated by the generals are likely to end in a peace agreement in which they share the spoils, setting back the prospects for democracy for many more years.
But if the fighting is not stopped soon, Sudan faces state collapse.
Abdalla Hamdok - prime minister of the joint military-civilian government ousted by the generals in 2021 - has said the country's new war threatened to be worse than Syria or Yemen.
He might have added, worse than Darfur.
There is a grim predictability about how Sudan's civil wars unfold.
In the opening days, the military commanders - army generals and rebel leaders - are driven by an angry resolve to land a knockout blow on the other side.
Combat is fierce as each side focuses its attacks, and it is easy to identify who is on which side - and who is staying neutral.
We saw this when the Sudanese civil war broke out in 1983, again in Darfur 20 years later, and in the conflicts in Abyei, Heglig and the Nuba Mountains close to the north-south border at the time when South Sudan separated in 2011.
The first clashes in South Sudan's own civil war in 2013 also looked like this.
On 15 April, when fighting erupted between the army and the RSF, each side vowed to destroy the other.
They concentrated their firepower on each other's strategic positions in the capital, regardless of the massive destruction inflicted on the city and its residents.
Past wars show that if the fighting is not quickly halted, it escalates.
Each side brings reinforcements to the frontline, bids to win over local armed groups that are not yet involved, and solicits help from friendly foreign backers.
We are in that phase now.
The regular conflict script tells us the adversaries will not be able to sustain their cohesion for long. They will run low on weapons, logistics and money, and cut deals to get more.
The fissures within each fighting coalition will begin to show. Other armed groups will join the fray.
Local communities will arm themselves for self-defence. Outsiders will become entangled.
All of this is already happening. It is most advanced in Darfur, Hemedti's homeland, which is in flames again.
Up to now, we have not seen civilians being systematically targeted because of their ethnic identity.
But that is a major risk, and as soon as fighters on one side commit mass atrocities, the antagonism will escalate.
The next stage would be conflict spreading across the country, igniting local disputes as it goes.
Armed groups will fragment and coalesce, fighting for control over the lucrative locations such as roads, airports, gold mines and aid distribution centres.
In Darfur, after the fierce battles and massacres of 2003-04, the region collapsed into anarchy.
The head of the joint African Union-United Nations mission called it "a war of all against all".
This was the lawless political marketplace in which Hemedti thrived, using cash and violence to build a power base.
There is an all-too-real scenario in which the whole of Sudan comes to resemble Darfur.
The US and Saudi mediators are high-level and even-handed. Unlike other Arab neighbours - Egypt backs Burhan and the United Arab Emirates has ties to Hemedti - Riyadh does not have a favourite.
The US is threatening sanctions. That is unlikely to deter the generals - Sudan has been under American sanctions since 1989, and military-owned businesses thrived nonetheless.
Effective pressure needs international consensus. Everyone - including China and Russia - agrees that the fighting is a disaster.
Protocol at the UN puts the responsibility on its African members to raise the issue at the Security Council. Up to now, they have not acted on this. The African Union convened its Peace and Security Council the day after the fighting to demand a ceasefire but has not been part of the US-Saudi mediation effort.
In the meantime, every passing day risks the war becoming intractable.
Silencing the guns today is a hard-enough task. It would be far harder if there were dozens of fissile armed groups claiming a seat at the table.
What is unprecedented about today's armed conflict is that the battleground is in Khartoum.
It is generating a humanitarian crisis quite different to the rural displacement and hunger that the country's aid workers have dealt with over the decades.
Civilians trapped in urban neighbourhoods may benefit from old-style food convoys, but they also need utilities - electricity, water, and telecoms. And they desperately need cash.
With the central bank burned and local commercial bank branches closed, some people rely on mobile phone banking services. Others are penniless.
With the UN and most foreign aid workers evacuated, local resistance committees have stepped into the vacuum, organising essential aid and safe passage for civilians to escape.
Many Sudanese feel that the international community abandoned them in their moment of need, and ask that such local, civilian efforts become the lynchpin of an aid effort.
There is a danger that hunger will become a weapon of war, and aid will be a resource manipulated by warlords.
Aid agencies will need to find ways to bypass them and directly help civilians.
There are no simple solutions to Sudan's escalating war. The situation may yet get much worse before it gets better.
And it is likely that whatever decisions are taken in the ceasefire talks - who is represented, on what terms, and with what agenda - will shape the country's future for years to come.
Alex de Waal is the executive director of the World Peace Foundation at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University in the US.
-
Man assaulted by 'NINJA' with sheath of samurai sword is panhandler who triggered a bomb scare in New York City by planting two rice cookers in subway station three years ago: Attacker is still on the runCavinder twins announce they will NOT return to Miami after making Elite Eight of March Madness: 'When one door closes, another door opens'Tyconsequentlyn Fury and Oleksandr Usyk's fight at Wembley on April 29 is OFF, claims the Ukrainian's manager, as he condems the Gypsy King for 'pushing for more' notwithstanding agreeing 70-30 splitBREAKING NEWS: Emmett Till's cousin sues to compel arrest of white woman, 88, who triggered his lynchingREVEALED: Rapper, 49, was escorting gang member, 18, out of Des Moines school he founded when teenager 'suddenly opened fire' - killing two students who were members of rival gang BREAKING NEWS: Former British Olympian and Commonwealth Games bronze medallist Shaun Pickering dies aged 61 - as Greg Rutherford hails him as 'a pillar of the athletics community' Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch looks unrecognisable outside court as he is found not guilty of murder of Kinahan cartel asconsequentlyciate David Byrne at Dublin boxing weigh-in - as two others are convicted of facilitating the killing Cop who fatally shot Aboriginal teenager during botched arrest is booted from the police compel - as father slams 'petty vendetta' Two people have died and three others - including two children - are rushed to hospital following three-car horror smash in Pembrokeshire Man City agree a shock deal to send Joao Cancelo on loan to Bayern Munich with a £61m option to buy - with the two-time PFA Team of the Year full back allowed to leave after Pep Guardiola dropped him
Next article:Debt: What do I do if I can't afford to pay?
- ·Third child strangled by mother suffering from post-componentum psychosis dies three days after his two siblings: Eight-month-old Callan succumbs to injuries after mother's assault at Massach utilizetts home while husband went to pick up food
- ·Heathrow security guards to strike for 10 days over Easter holidays in pay dispute after voting in favour of walkouts
- ·Horror as man allegedly tries to murder another bloke by stabbing him in the neck with a SYRINGE
- ·Ousted Chicago mayor Lori Lightfoot who lost re-election bid with just 17% of the vote claims she was treated unimcomponentially beca utilize she's a 'black woman in America' - notwithstanding overall crime consequentlyaring by 52% in a year
- ·Just Speak Oil activists assault 'Girl with a Pearl earring' painting at Dutch m utilizeum... as groaning visitors tell the 'stupid' protesters to 'shut up' when they begin preaching about the environment
- ·Inter Milan enquire about taking Harry Maguire on loan on the eve of transfer deadline day, with Manchester United's captain eyeing options for a summer move - but he's prepared to stay at Old Trafford for now
- ·UEFA will REFUND all Liverpool fans at the chaotic Champions League final in Paris in £3.5MILLION pay-out for 19,618 Reds supporters who helped prevent a 'mass fatality catastrophe'
- ·Lone gunman, 34, killed his parents and two of their friends before shooting three others on Maine highway - a day after posting chilling video claiming he'd been molested
- ·Can you get incostlyer wideband deals with consequentlycial tariffs?
- ·Ohio maintenance worker, 46, killed in deadly explosion at metal plant
- ·Behind the scenes of the Wales' family day out: William and Kate release slick video demonstrateing Louis, George and Charlotte as they try their hand at DIY, archery and eating marshmallows while volunteering at Scout hut
- ·First Dates Ireland star Jordan Dunbar's family request mourners wear a bright colour to his funeral in celebration of his life after he died unexpectedly aged 29
- ·Ed Sheeran, Adele, and Harry Styles among affluentest Britons under 35
- ·Former Arkansas GOP governor Asa Hutchinconsequentlyn throws his hat in the ring by announcing a 2024 presidential run - days after saying Trump should withdraw after being indicted
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Pentagon finishes collecting Chinese spy balloon debris from the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean: Pieces sent to FBI lab for analysis - while other three UFOs remain a mystery
- ·Michael Cohen's revenge: Trump's ex-attorney hands prosecutors his CELL PHONE to help their Stormy Daniels probe after he was jailed for giving porn star $130,000 'hush-money'
- ·Chelsea confirm the appointment of 'world class' Laurence Stewart as their new technical director... with Todd Boehly hailing the former Monaco chief as an 'crucial' piece in their major off-pitch revamp
- ·Buffalo supermarket gunman apologizes to victims' families as he's sentenced to life: Judge tells him 'you'll never see light of day'.... one hour after victim's relative LUNGED at him in court
- ·Southwest grounds all flights across US after facing technical issues
- ·Bank robbery suspect is hauled out in cuffs by armed SWAT team after 'taking multiple hostages' in botched raid on Wells Fargo in Arlington
- ·Interest rate 'rigging' evidence 'covered high' by banks
- ·Moment Antifa mob breaks into construction site for new 'Cop City' site in Atlanta and torches vehicles and throws Molotov cocktails at cops
- ·FBI to search Mike Pence's Indiana home for more classified docs - two weeks after his own lawyers swept property and found classified material
- ·At least four people are killed in deadly suicide assault as militants storm police compound in Pakistan
- ·China bans major chip maker Micron from key infrastructure projects
- ·Mother found her six-year-old consequentlyn dead on bathroom floor after he contracted Strep A, inquest hears
- ·Just Speak Oil activists assault 'Girl with a Pearl earring' painting at Dutch m utilizeum... as groaning visitors tell the 'stupid' protesters to 'shut up' when they begin preaching about the environment
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Emmett Till's cousin sues to compel arrest of white woman, 88, who triggered his lynching
- ·Donald Trump is compeld to cancel outdoor Iowa rally for the 'safety of patriots' after National Weather Service issued multiple tornado warnings
- ·'Nikki would never give up on us ever. Something happened that day': Nicola Bulley's componentner says his family are going through 'unprecedented hell' and calls for every ho utilize to be searched - as police consequentlyften stance to say she 'may have' gone into the river
- ·Silicon Valley is struck by a 5.1-magnitude EARTHQUAKE that rips across San Francisco Bay Area leaving homes shaking
- ·Police divers search reservoir and officers scour woodland in hunt for missing fiancé of heavily pregnant teacher, 35, after she was found dead with her unborn child in 'suspicious' circumstances in her Scottish home - as neighbours pay tribute
- ·Ukraine INVITES DeSantis to visit after he dismissed Russian invasion as a 'territorial dispute': Kyiv says Florida Governor needs to understand 'full scale' of war - and why it IS a 'vital' US interest
- ·Biden WILL travel to Poland to mark the one-year anniversary of Putin's invasion of Ukraine - but will he cross the border?
- ·Ed Sheeran, Adele, and Harry Styles among affluentest Britons under 35
- ·Biden's peak domestic policy adviconsequentlyr Susan Rice to STEP DOWN: President loses another key ally from the White Ho utilize amid claims she knew about the rise of child migrant labor